U.S. Department
of Justice
Public Workshop on Venture Capital and Antitrust
Paul Brest Hall Stanford University
555 Salvatierra Walk
Standford, CA 94305
United States
Event Details
Workshop Information
The Department of Justice and Stanford University held a public workshop on Feb. 12, 2020, to explore the intersection between venture capital and antitrust law. The full-day workshop covered trends in venture capital investment from the 1990s through present, with a focus on what antitrust enforcers can learn from investors about how to identify nascent competitors in markets dominated by technology platforms. The workshop also addressed proposed solutions to concerns that competitive alternatives to the market-leading platforms are not attractive investment opportunities.
The Justice Department’s Antitrust Division and the Stanford Graduate School of Business co-hosted the workshop, which brought together venture capitalists, academics from both law and business, and other tech industry stakeholders. The Antitrust Division and Stanford explored the practical considerations that early stage investors face when calculating the risks of investing in a startup and exit strategies.
Press Release: Department of Justice Antitrust Division to Co-Host Workshop on Venture Capital Investment and Antitrust Law with Stanford University (January 14, 2020)
Date and Location
|
February 12, 2020 |
Paul Brest Hall Stanford University 555 Salvatierra Walk Stanford, CA 94305 |
Workshop Agenda
Event Transcript| 9:00–9:10 a.m. |
Opening Remarks
Makan Delrahim, Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division, U.S. Department of Justice |
| 9:10–10:10 a.m. |
Fireside Chat with Michael Moritz: Trends in VC Investment: How did we get here?
Michael Moritz, a partner at Sequoia Capital, will discuss trends in start-up investment from the 1990s through the present with Professor Joseph Grundfest, the William A. Franke Professor of Law and Business at Stanford Law School. Mr. Moritz will share anecdotes about early VC investment and discuss what can be learned from them. Topics may also include a discussion of early industry and regulatory challenges and how the investment community overcame them. |
| 10:10–10:35 a.m. |
Antitrust for VCs: A Discussion with Stanford Law Professor Doug Melamed
Doug Melamed, Professor of the Practice of Law at Stanford Law School, will give an overview of antitrust law and enforcement as it may relate to venture capital investment. Professor Melamed will discuss the general aspects of merger review, including relevant recent mergers related to the tech industry and nascent competition. He will also describe both unilateral conduct (i.e., tying, exclusive dealing, predatory pricing and other exclusionary conduct), and coordinated conduct (e.g., no poach enforcement among tech companies). Professor Melamed will introduce the role of antitrust law and enforcement in the business of venture capital and tee up the question of how the relationship between the two can be improved. |
| 10:35–10:50 a.m. |
Coffee Break |
| 10:50 a.m.–12:05 p.m. |
Panel 1: What explains the Kill Zones? Some fear that certain technology companies have created “kill zones,” or markets in which starting new companies is no longer worthwhile. Panelists will discuss the various market characteristics and industry conduct that may contribute to kill zones, including the role of network effects, property rights, and other barriers to entry. Panelists will discuss the pros and cons of investing in anticipated markets (e.g., 5G) and how to predict when markets tip. Panelists Paul Arnold, Founder and Partner, Switch Ventures Roger McNamee, Co-Founder and Managing Director, Elevation Partners Ram Shriram, Managing Partner, Sherpalo Ventures LLC Ilya Strebulaev, David S. Lobel Professor of Private Equity and Professor of Finance, Stanford Graduate School of Business Susan Woodward, Founder, Sand Hill Econometrics DOJ Moderator: David Lawrence, Chief, Competition Policy & Advocacy Section, Antitrust Division, U.S. Department of Justice. |
| 12:05–1:00 p.m. |
Lunch Break |
| 1:00-1:10 p.m. |
Afternoon Remarks
Dean Jonathan Levin, Stanford Graduate School of Business |
| 1:10–2:30 p.m. |
Panel 2: Monetizing Data Panelists will discuss the role of data in tech markets, both as an effective entry barrier and a means to protect investment. They will describe how rivals collect or access data, how they sell it, and whether data should be treated differently from other capital-intensive entry investments. The panel will also address the options available to protect incentives while encouraging competition (e.g., data portability). Panelists Susan Athey, The Economics of Technology Professor; Director, Golub Capital Social Impact Lab at Stanford GSB Greg Back, Managing Member, Free Sky Capital Ari Paparo, Co-Founder and CEO, Beeswax Kelland Reilly, Managing Director, General Atlantic DOJ Moderator: Ryan Shores, Associate Deputy Attorney General and Senior Advisor for Technology Industries, U.S. Department of Justice |
| 2:30–3:45 p.m. |
Panel 3: Investing in platform-dominated markets Panelists will discuss the proper frameworks for evaluating internet platforms. For example, panelist will debate whether internet platform incentives are unique from other platforms to support a separate analytical framework and how to balance the inherent market power of an efficient platform with the potential for abuse. They will also discuss the pros and cons of building on top of on an existing platform and how to build a successful product or service in a platform dominated market. Panelists Nick Grossman, Partner, Union Square Ventures Mark Lemley, Professor, Stanford Law School; Partner, Durie Tangri LLP Patricia Nakache, General Partner, Trinity Ventures Ben Thompson, Founder, Stratechery DOJ Moderator: Karina Lubell, Attorney Advisor, Competition Policy & Advocacy Section, Antitrust Division, U.S. Department of Justice |
| 3:45–4:00 p.m. |
Coffee Break |
| 4:00–5:00 p.m. |
Roundtable: Is there a problem and what is the solution? This roundtable will recap the discussion from the workshop and participants will provide reactions to what was discussed. Members of the roundtable will also describe the potential for regulatory solutions to address the concerns highlighted during the workshop and the effects—both positive and negative—of those regulatory solutions. Panelists Erik Hovenkamp, Assistant Professor of Law at Gould School of Law, University of Southern California Connie Loizos, Silicon Valley Editor at TechCrunch, Founder of StrictlyVC Ted Ullyot, Adjunct Professor at Antonin Scalia Law School, George Mason University (formerly Partner at Andreessen Horowitz, General Counsel at Facebook) DOJ Moderator: Taylor Owings, Counsel to the Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division, U.S. Department of Justice |
| 5:00–5:10 p.m. |
Closing Remarks
Manish Kumar, Chief of the San Francisco Office, Antitrust Division, U.S. Department of Justice |
View the opening remarks by Makan DelrahimPublic Comment Submissions
The Department of Justice invited comments from the public on the topics covered by this workshop. The deadline for submitting comments was March 14, 2020. The comment period is now closed.
Privacy and confidentiality: Written submissions and the identity of the submitter may be disclosed, reproduced, and distributed by publication and/or posting on the Department of Justice website, at the discretion of the Department of Justice. Information that is submitted in connection with this event cannot be maintained as confidential by the Department of Justice. Written submissions should not include any information that the submitting person seeks to preserve as private or confidential.